Nyx Book Reviews

fantasy ♥ paranormal ♥ horror ♥ science-fiction

Review: Jackaby by William Ritter

Title: Jackaby
Author: William Ritter
Series: Jackaby #1
Rating: 3 Stars

299 pages
Published September 16th 2014 by Algonquin Young Readers

Goodreads | Amazon | Book Depository

Jackaby was one of my most anticipated 2014 releases. It has a beautiful cover, a great blurb, and honestly just sounded so good. A paranormal Sherlock Holmes? Count me in!

Abigail Rook doesn’t want to live a life of pretty dresses, but one of adventure and excitement. That’s how she ends up on a different continent, penniless, looking for a job. She finds employment by the eccentric Jackaby, a young man who solves paranormal mysteries.

It’s clear that Mr Ritter is an absolute fan of old detectives. There are countless allusions to the grandfathers of the genre, including to Poe (there is both a character named Allan, as well as one named Dupin). Ritter knows his source material, but that is also his greatest weakness. Jackaby as a character is described as “Sherlock Holmes meets Doctor Who”, which is exactly who he is. He is simply a mash-up of the personality of these two pop-culture heroes, and he never breaks from the mould into becoming a character of his own. He struts around like the Doctor, and deduces like Holmes. There isn’t more to him than this flat characterisation.

Abigail herself isn’t much better – like many detective sidekicks she is simply a foil, a stand-in for the reader so we can enjoy the work of the detective in her place. There is a shallow back story that never fully takes form, and she’s hardly an acting character at all. Mr Ritter deserves a cookie, however, for writing a story with a male and female character in close quarters to each other without there being any romantic feelings between them.

On a sentence level Jackaby is fantastically written. I think this is where Ritter’s expertise shines most. He has a very convincing 19th century voice, something that isn’t easy to accomplish. He also writes entertaining banter and seems to have a great imagination for mythological beasties and paranormal occurrences.

I quite liked this debut, because in the end these archetypical characters are very entertaining. It took a bit to get used to the fact that Jackaby investigates brownies and trolls instead of normal human beings, but when I got into the story, I enjoyed the ride. Jackaby wasn’t exactly what I was expecting, but I will read the next book.


Newly arrived in New Fiddleham, New England, 1892, and in need of a job, Abigail Rook meets R. F. Jackaby, an investigator of the unexplained with a keen eye for the extraordinary–including the ability to see supernatural beings. Abigail has a gift for noticing ordinary but important details, which makes her perfect for the position of Jackaby’s assistant. On her first day, Abigail finds herself in the midst of a thrilling case: A serial killer is on the loose. The police are convinced it’s an ordinary villain, but Jackaby is certain it’s a nonhuman creature, whose existence the police–with the exception of a handsome young detective named Charlie Cane–deny.

Other reviews you might be interested in
  • Midwinterblood by Marcus Sedgwick
  • The Midnight Queen by Sylvia Izzo Hunter
  • The Cure for Dreaming by Cat Winters
  • Ripper by Amy Carol Reeves
  • , , , , , , , , ,

    • http://whats--hot.net/ Laura Hartley

      Sherlock Holmes meets Doctor Who sounds like an amazing combination! It’s a shame that you say the characters are a bit flat :/ I don’t know how I haven’t hear of this yet, I think I’m going to give it a try! Great review 🙂

      Laura @ What’s Hot?

      • http://www.nyxbookreviews.com/ Celine

        I’m hoping the characters get better as the series progresses 🙂 I hope you like it!

    • http://zoereads.org/ Zoe N.

      Sherlock Holmes meets Doctor Who? WOW – that almost sounds too good to be true! Definitely going to have to get a copy of this – it sounds great. It’s a shame that the characters were a bit flat, but other than that it sounds amazing. Thanks for sharing and, as always, fabulous review! <3
      ~Zoe @ Stories on Stage

      • http://www.nyxbookreviews.com/ Celine

        Haha, it does have the best pitch, doesn’t it? I hope you enjoy Jackaby if you get round to it. Thanks a lot, Zoe <3

    • Cindy

      This book sounds good! I have not heard of it but thanks for sharing this great review!

      • http://www.nyxbookreviews.com/ Celine

        Thank you for stopping by Cindy!

    • Bea @ Bea’s Book Nook

      I enjoyed this one, even though the characterization fell flat at times. Ritter’s love for mysteries really did shine through and I agree about his voice. 🙂

      • http://www.nyxbookreviews.com/ Celine

        I really enjoyed all of the little references he made to other detectives

    • http://www.thequietpeople.com/ Beth

      Oh… I LOVE the idea for this novel, but it sounds like it wasn’t executed particularly well, which is a shame. I’ve actually just finished The Clockwork Scarab by Colleen Gleason, which is based on a kind of similar premise – Shelrock Holmes’ neice meets Bram Stoker’s sister – but again, that wasn’t mind blowing. We need more awesome Victorian retellings, please!
      Beth x

      • http://www.nyxbookreviews.com/ Celine

        Yes! Especially because all of the Victorian classics are such an amazing source material. If only there were a Penny Dreadful in the bookish world (I love that TV show).

    • Pingback: Review: This Monstrous Thing by Mackenzie Lee | Nyx Book Reviews()